My suspicion of decaf coffee is only heightened by the rhetoric used to defend it.

"This decaf is not like other decafs."

"This decaf is nearly indistinguishable from regular coffee."

And so forth.

The language assumes in advance an objection...and with good reason. Most decafs are awful, some are acceptable, fewer still are tasty. I might be exaggerating the extent of that final category...I've yet to encounter a tasty decaf. It is a mythical thing to be wished for, a solar-powered car, or something.

Last spring I tried Intelligentsia's Librarian Blend, their decaf offering. It was in the acceptable category, jumping juuuust high enough to escape the awful. It was overly dark, oils on the surface, mostly just roast flavor. From Intelligentsia! The darling of acidity-lovers everywhere!

But decaffeination is a volatile process. It's not difficult to remove the caffeine from beans. What's difficult is removing the caffeine without inflicting too much damage on all the tasty extractables that make coffee worth our while. Mountain water process, Swiss process, Canadian process...like your friendly neighborhood vegan is quick to tell you, beware processed foods! Decaffeinated coffees are the most processed of coffees and not coincidentally, they tend to be among the least tasty. To cover up the damage done by the decaffeination process, decafs tend to be roasted dark, often too dark.

But I am currently sipping on the Librarian Blend once again, and I have to say--it's tasty! Currant aroma, the taste a little thin and the finish short, but it's not dominated by roast flavor, it's got a little sweetness. Okay, maybe it's more in the acceptable category. It tried to inch itself into the tasty category--nobly! for this is a difficult thing for a decaf coffee to do, mind you--but it did not quite clear the bar. I will give it another try in a season or two. Technology advances. One day we'll have that car, and perhaps a tasty decaf.

Blog Category: 

Comments

Submitted by EricBNC on
<br>We cover the bases very well here in the blog section when it comes to high test, but not too often does a post about decaf come along - thanks for sharing your impressions.

Submitted by jbviau on
...what are your thoughts on non-alcoholic beer? ;) Seriously, though, glad to hear decaf is making progress.

Submitted by donnedonne on
Deep Cello is one of the roasters whose following I can understand, but their muted, low-acidity, funky-natural style isn't for me. But perhaps they've changed Black Tie since the time I tried it, there were some weird savory elements in the cup for me.

Thank you for bringing this decaffeinated coffee to our attention. I have never tried a decaffinated coffee before (and never have any need to) and I'm interested in may be trying some just to know what it is all about.

Intelligentsia Librarian Blend (Decaf)

| by

My suspicion of decaf coffee is only heightened by the rhetoric used to defend it.

"This decaf is not like other decafs."

"This decaf is nearly indistinguishable from regular coffee."

And so forth.

The language assumes in advance an objection...and with good reason. Most decafs are awful, some are acceptable, fewer still are tasty. I might be exaggerating the extent of that final category...I've yet to encounter a tasty decaf. It is a mythical thing to be wished for, a solar-powered car, or something.

Last spring I tried Intelligentsia's Librarian Blend, their decaf offering. It was in the acceptable category, jumping juuuust high enough to escape the awful. It was overly dark, oils on the surface, mostly just roast flavor. From Intelligentsia! The darling of acidity-lovers everywhere!

But decaffeination is a volatile process. It's not difficult to remove the caffeine from beans. What's difficult is removing the caffeine without inflicting too much damage on all the tasty extractables that make coffee worth our while. Mountain water process, Swiss process, Canadian process...like your friendly neighborhood vegan is quick to tell you, beware processed foods! Decaffeinated coffees are the most processed of coffees and not coincidentally, they tend to be among the least tasty. To cover up the damage done by the decaffeination process, decafs tend to be roasted dark, often too dark.

But I am currently sipping on the Librarian Blend once again, and I have to say--it's tasty! Currant aroma, the taste a little thin and the finish short, but it's not dominated by roast flavor, it's got a little sweetness. Okay, maybe it's more in the acceptable category. It tried to inch itself into the tasty category--nobly! for this is a difficult thing for a decaf coffee to do, mind you--but it did not quite clear the bar. I will give it another try in a season or two. Technology advances. One day we'll have that car, and perhaps a tasty decaf.

Category: BLOG

Thanks for the review. Its

April 23, 2012 | by hoonchul@hotmail.com

Thanks for the review. Its good to know that decaf is making progress, who knows I may need to start drinking it in the future.

very interesting coffee!

April 20, 2012 | by sontondaman

Thank you for bringing this decaffeinated coffee to our attention. I have never tried a decaffinated coffee before (and never have any need to) and I'm interested in may be trying some just to know what it is all about.

Deep Cello is one of the

April 20, 2012 | by donnedonne

Deep Cello is one of the roasters whose following I can understand, but their muted, low-acidity, funky-natural style isn't for me. But perhaps they've changed Black Tie since the time I tried it, there were some weird savory elements in the cup for me.

Yeah I have been pleasantly

April 20, 2012 | by intrepid510

Yeah I have been pleasantly surprised with the new decals I have tried, they are getting better. The deep cello one here is real good too.

So...

April 19, 2012 | by jbviau

...what are your thoughts on non-alcoholic beer? ;) Seriously, though, glad to hear decaf is making progress.

Thanks

April 19, 2012 | by EricBNC


We cover the bases very well here in the blog section when it comes to high test, but not too often does a post about decaf come along - thanks for sharing your impressions.

Categories

  • http://coffeekind.com/sites/default/files/icon_blog_on.png

    BLOG

  • http://coffeekind.com/sites/default/files/icon_knowledge1_on.png

    KNOWLEDGE

  • http://coffeekind.com/sites/default/files/icon_news_on.png

    NEWS

  • http://coffeekind.com/sites/default/files/icon_guides_on_1.png

    BREWING GUIDES

  • http://coffeekind.com/sites/default/files/icon_buying_guides_on_1.png

    BUYING GUIDES

  • http://coffeekind.com/sites/default/files/drink_guide_1.png

    DRINK GUIDES

  • http://coffeekind.com/sites/default/files/recipehover.png

    RECIPES

  • http://coffeekind.com/sites/default/files/latest%20reviews.png

    LATEST REVIEWS